ACT TWOGet started
Guide

Pre-tax versus after-tax views

A pre-tax split shows what each party receives. An after-tax split shows what each party keeps. This guide covers why the baseline starts pre-tax, and when to switch the view.

November 19, 20265 min read

Most settlement discussions begin with statement values. That is the right place to begin. It is not always the right place to end.

Why the baseline starts pre-tax

A pre-tax value is a fact both sides can check. It is the balance on the statement or the figure in the appraisal. Nobody has to agree on an assumption before agreeing on the number.

An after-tax value is a projection. To state it, you need three things that are not on the statement:

  • Cost basis, which may take time to document.
  • A tax rate, which depends on the holder's future income, filing status and state.
  • A plan: whether the asset will be sold, and when. An asset that is never sold may never produce the tax.

Starting pre-tax keeps the reference point free of argument. The 50-50 baseline is then a number neither side can dispute, and every assumption added afterward is visible as an assumption.

Why pre-tax is not enough

Under federal law, a transfer of property between spouses as part of a divorce generally triggers no gain or loss. That makes the division itself tax-neutral. It also means the tax does not disappear. The person who receives the asset takes over its original cost basis, and with it the gain that has built up.

So two assets with the same value today can carry very different tax bills later.

  • Cash is worth its face value.
  • Appreciated investments carry a gain that is taxed when they are sold.
  • Pre-tax retirement accounts are taxed as income when money is withdrawn, and dividing them usually needs a specific court order or transfer procedure to avoid tax at the time of division.
  • A primary home may qualify for an exclusion on some of the gain when sold, subject to ownership and use rules.
  • A private company interest often has a low basis, but the tax only matters if a sale is expected.

Support payments have their own treatment. For federal purposes, maintenance under agreements made after 2018 is generally not deductible by the payer and not income to the recipient. State treatment can differ.

A worked example

Take the scenario from sample case 014 in which Party B keeps the home.

Party AParty B
Private company interest$500,000
Brokerage account$420,000
Primary home (equity)$1,100,000
Equalizing payment+$90,000−$90,000
Pre-tax total$1,010,000$1,010,000
Figures in articles come from sample case 014, which is fictional. The cost basis and tax rate below are assumed for illustration only.

Pre-tax, this is an exact 50-50 split. Now enter a cost basis of $240,000 for the brokerage account. It holds a $180,000 gain. Suppose Party A expects to sell the account to fund the next few years, at an assumed combined tax rate of 25%. The sale costs $45,000 in tax.

Party AParty B
Pre-tax total$1,010,000$1,010,000
Tax on brokerage sale−$45,000
After-tax total$965,000$1,010,000

The split that looked equal is $45,000 apart. One way to close the gap is to raise the equalizing payment by $22,500, to $112,500. Each party then holds $987,500 after tax.

Note what the after-tax view depends on. If Party A never sells, the tax is not paid. If Party B sells the home in five years, a different tax may arise on that side. The after-tax number is only as good as the assumptions behind it, which is why they should be written down next to it.

Pre-tax tells you what each party receives. After-tax tells you what each party keeps. A settlement needs both, in that order.

When to switch the view

Stay pre-tax to establish the baseline and agree the inventory. Switch to after-tax when:

  • Assets with different tax characters are being traded against each other, such as a retirement account for home equity.
  • One party is likely to sell what they receive in the near term.
  • An equalizing payment is being sized.
  • One party is being asked to take most of the appreciated assets.
  • The two sides agree on the split but one feels shortchanged and cannot say why.

How Act Two helps

  • Pre-tax is the default. The 50-50 baseline divides marital assets on a pre-tax basis, so every case starts from verifiable numbers.
  • After-tax is one switch away once cost basis is entered. The same scenarios can be read both ways without rebuilding the case.
  • Every scenario shows its assumptions, so the basis and rate behind an after-tax figure can be checked by the professional before it is used.
  • A rules-based calculation layer recomputes every total and share. Scenarios whose figures do not match are not shown.
  • Side-by-side comparison makes the gap between the two views visible across two to four scenarios, with the baseline always included.

Act Two does not give tax advice. The after-tax view is a planning aid for the advisor or attorney, and tax treatment should be confirmed with a tax professional for each case.

This article is general information for professionals. It is not legal advice.

Priced by the case

Pay only for the cases you run, from a single matter to a firm’s full caseload. No subscription, and no limit on users on the Practice and Firm plans.

View pricing